Retinoids in Skincare: Which One Should You Choose?

For years, retinoids have been hailed as a game-changer in skincare. Initially, they were primarily used as potent anti-aging agents or to combat severe acne. But with advancements in the beauty industry, retinoids have become the go-to active ingredient for skincare routines, especially during the fall and winter months.

Gone are the days when retinol products were notorious for being uncomfortable to use and fraught with side effects. Today’s formulations feature various retinoid forms designed for better tolerance. Add to this the hype from social media influencers, and it’s no wonder that people are picking up retinoids out of sheer curiosity, hoping for magical skin transformations.

However, we strongly discourage this impulsive approach. To truly reap the benefits of retinoids, you must choose products based on your skin’s needs rather than social media trends. Especially since retinoids are a serious skincare ingredient.

We’ve previously discussed what retinoids are, the results you can expect from them, and whether they might be right for you. You can read more about it in this article.

If you’ve decided retinoids are right for you, let’s dive into the different forms available to find the one that suits your skin best.

---

What Are Retinoids, and How Do They Work?

You’ve likely heard the term “retinol” used as a catch-all for retinoids. But retinoids are actually a broad class of vitamin A derivatives, with retinol being just one type.

Retinoids work by converting into the active form, retinoic acid, which interacts directly with skin cells. Other forms of retinoids are inactive and must go through conversion steps to become retinoic acid. The fewer conversion steps required, the quicker the retinoid works.

However, faster isn’t always better. Stronger retinoids, like pure retinoic acid, can irritate the skin and even cause retinoid dermatitis if used incorrectly. That’s why finding the right balance of efficacy and comfort is key.

---

Popular Types of Retinoids

1. Retinyl Palmitate
This is the gentlest form of vitamin A, working only on the skin’s surface. While you won’t get dramatic results, it serves as a mild antioxidant and can even be used in your daytime routine.

• Benefits: Slightly brightens skin tone and improves texture.
• Best for: Beginners and those with sensitive skin.

2. Retinol
A classic choice, retinol works deeper to renew the skin, reduce breakouts, fade pigmentation, and smooth wrinkles. However, it can be harsh and is often encapsulated in modern formulations to reduce irritation.

• Benefits: Promotes cell turnover, tackles post-acne marks, and minimizes fine lines.
• Best for: Acne-prone, pigmented, or aging skin.

3. Retinal (Retinaldehyde)
More stable than retinol, retinal works faster and is slightly less irritating. It also has antibacterial properties, making it ideal for acne-prone skin.

• Benefits: Reduces acne, fades post-acne marks, and smooths skin texture.
• Best for: Oily or combination skin prone to breakouts.

---

Prescription Retinoids

Sometimes, over-the-counter products aren’t enough. In such cases, a dermatologist might prescribe stronger retinoids, such as adapalene or tretinoin.

Adapalene
A synthetic retinoid that’s stable and relatively mild, adapalene is highly effective in treating acne without the severe irritation often associated with other forms.

• Benefits: Reduces comedones, prevents new breakouts, and soothes redness.
• Best for: Acne-prone skin or those seeking effective results with minimal irritation.

Tretinoin (Retinoic Acid)
This is the active form of vitamin A and works directly on skin cells. While it’s highly effective against severe acne, pigmentation, and deep wrinkles, it can be very irritating and is available only by prescription.

• Benefits: Effectively addresses serious issues like acne, deep wrinkles, and hyperpigmentation.
• Best for: Serious skin concerns as prescribed by a dermatologist.

---

Next-Generation Retinoids

For those seeking a balance between efficacy and comfort, new retinoid forms offer exciting options.

Retinyl Retinoate
A revolutionary combination of retinol and retinoic acid in one molecule. When applied, it splits into two active components—one working immediately and the other gradually. This ensures effective results with minimal irritation.

• Benefits: Boosts elasticity, stimulates collagen production, reduces wrinkles, and brightens pigmentation.
• Best for: Mature or sensitive skin looking for powerful yet gentle anti-aging benefits.

Hydroxypinacolone Retinoate (HPR)
A game-changer, HPR works directly without needing conversion to retinoic acid. It offers predictable results with minimal risk of irritation.

• Benefits: Reduces inflammation, clears pores, smooths skin, and softens fine lines.
• Best for: Those wary of irritation but seeking retinoid benefits, including sensitive or acne-prone skin.

---

How to Start Using Retinoids

• Start Slowly: Introduce retinoids into your nighttime routine 1–2 times a week and monitor your skin’s response. Gradually increase usage if there’s no irritation.
• Focus on Recovery: Retinoids can compromise the skin barrier, so include restorative products in your routine.
• Never Skip Sunscreen: Retinoids increase sun sensitivity, making SPF non-negotiable—even on cloudy days.

---

Retinoids aren’t a magic wand but a powerful tool requiring mindful use. There’s no “best” or “worst” retinoid; their effectiveness depends on the formula, concentration, texture, and, most importantly, your individual skin needs and preferences.

Remember, the key is to listen to your skin and choose products that feel comfortable rather than those trending on social media.